A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch)

A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch): Introduction

A rider crosses a clearing towards a small white inn. Beyond the buildings, the road disappears into a narrow opening between wooded slopes, while an immense mountain rises above them. Autumn foliage glows beneath clouds that darken the left side of the sky. In Thomas Cole's A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch), human movement seems both perfectly ordinary and extraordinarily small.

Painted in 1839, this oil on canvas belongs to the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC. Its subject is a real New Hampshire landscape, but Cole shaped the view through drawing, memory and invention. The contrast between welcoming shelter and overwhelming mountains makes the painting more than a picturesque record of a journey. ^{[1] [2]}

At a Glance

• ArtistThomas Cole.
• Date1839.
• MediumOil on canvas.
• Dimensions102 × 155.8 cm.
• CollectionNational Gallery of Art, Washington, DC; Andrew W. Mellon Fund.
• Accession1967.8.1.
• SubjectCrawford Notch, New Hampshire; the white building is the Notch House inn. ^{[1] [2]}

Contents

1. Introduction
2. Entering the mountain pass
3. A place Cole knew through repeated journeys
4. An American companion to an Italian landscape
5. From a July drawing to an autumn painting
6. Travellers beneath changing skies
7. The Willey disaster and the house in the picture
8. Cut trees, enduring mountains
9. From Lord's collection to Washington
10. Photographs and the changing experience of the pass

Entering the mountain pass

Cole gives the viewer a wide foreground but a constricted destination. At the bottom of the canvas, broken trunks, stones and low vegetation stretch across the scene. Water opens a quieter patch on the left; the road enters from the right. These horizontal spaces let the eye move comfortably before it encounters the steep ascent of the hills. The notch itself is a thin, dark interval near the centre, a passage that seems almost too small for the landscape surrounding it.

The white inn sits to the left of this opening, its pale walls visible through autumn trees. A barn stands farther right. Between them, the clearing has an irregular, worked appearance, with scattered stumps and uneven ground. The arrangement is legible without becoming geometrically tidy. Cole makes it possible to imagine walking or riding into the scene, yet he also leaves rough obstacles close to the viewer.

Mount Webster dominates the distance. Its great exposed face is warmer in colour than the darkest trees beneath it, but clouds partly obscure its profile. The mountain occupies an enormous amount of pictorial space in comparison with the buildings. That disproportion is central to the experience of looking: the inn can draw our attention without commanding the valley. The trees, road and roofs give us familiar measures against which to feel the mountain's size.

Franklin Kelly's catalogue study identifies the rocky projection at the left as the Elephant's Head and explains that Cole made the topography more dramatic than the actual site. Mount Webster became steeper, while the walls of the pass were drawn closer together. The painting therefore preserves recognisable features while intensifying their relationship. It offers a persuasive experience of Crawford Notch rather than a neutral measurement of its terrain. ^[2]

This distinction matters because the picture's long title sounds descriptive. It tells us where to look, but it does not promise that every spatial relationship has been copied unchanged. Cole's achievement depends on joining the credibility of an observed place to the force of a composed image. The narrow opening, the high mountain and the low clearing become mutually expressive: each makes the others seem more pronounced.

Annotated Details from View of a Mountain Pass Called the Notch

Compare four details with the full composition, then open the photographs for a closer view.

Details from VIEW OF A MOUNTAIN PASS CALLED THE NOTCH

Each crop comes from the same painting shown above.

1

The mountain above the pass

Mount Webster occupies an immense part of the view, dwarfing the buildings below. Kelly explains how Cole steepened its face and narrowed the pass when developing his field drawing. ^[2]

2

The Notch House

The white inn stands among autumn trees. It is the Notch House, established in 1828, rather than the Willey House associated with the fatal slide two years earlier. ^[2]

3

The rider on the road

A lone rider moves towards the inn, while the road leads onwards through the mountains. The figure supplies human scale; its personal identity is not securely established. ^[2]

4

Cut and broken trees

Sawn stumps and broken wood interrupt the near ground. Their different forms bring deliberate clearing and natural damage into the same foreground. ^[2]

A place Cole knew through repeated journeys

Cole's interest in the White Mountains began well before this canvas. His patron Daniel Wadsworth travelled there in 1826 and recommended the region to him the following year, supplying an itinerary. Cole's 1827 journey introduced him to scenery that subsequently appeared in several paintings. Elizabeth Mankin Kornhauser's study of his American landscapes places Wadsworth's guidance within a wider culture of travel, geological interest and patronage. Artists did not discover these views in isolation; recommendations, travel accounts and prospective buyers helped shape the journeys they made. ^{[2] [4]}

For Cole, the mountains also encouraged a sense of human smallness. In a letter to Wadsworth dated 4 August 1827, quoted by Kelly, he associated sublime scenery with an awareness of humanity's insignificance. The important point is the relationship between physical scale and feeling. Mountains could be admired for their forms and colours while also prompting thoughts that exceeded the immediate view. ^[2]

His earlier treatment of Crawford Notch included an 1828 drawing and a design for a lithograph concerning the slides that had destroyed the Willey family. The print was intended for publication by Anthony Imbert but apparently was not distributed. Kelly notes that there is no evidence for the sometimes proposed lost oil painting behind it. These earlier works belong to the history of Cole's attention to the region; they should not be mistaken for versions of the 1839 canvas or used to reconstruct an undocumented painting. ^[2]

Cole returned to the White Mountains in late June and early July 1839 with his fellow painter Asher B. Durand. They were at Crawford Notch by 3 July, a date supported by an inscription on Durand's drawing. Cole produced a detailed pencil study of the view, now in the Princeton University Art Museum. Its extensive notations and carefully recorded features suggest, in Kelly's judgement, that he already had a finished painting in mind. ^[2]

That study anchors the finished canvas in a particular act of observation. Cole did not simply remember a spectacular mountain from a distant visit. He gathered information about the profile, buildings and landscape during the summer journey. The subsequent transformations are meaningful precisely because there was a substantial record to transform. His practice combined the patient attention of a traveller with the freedom of an artist working towards a larger composition.

An American companion to an Italian landscape

The immediate occasion for the painting was a commission from Rufus L. Lord, a wealthy New York collector. Lord had met Cole in Florence during the artist's first European journey. In June 1831 he commissioned a picture for a mantelpiece in his house, leaving the choice of scene to Cole. The resulting Landscape Composition: Italian Scenery, completed in 1832, brought together a shrine, bridge, ruined tower, hill town and figures. It was a composite Italian landscape rather than a transcript of one viewpoint. ^[2]

The researched chronology in Thomas Cole's Journey: Atlantic Crossings dates Lord's commission to 25 June 1831 and the completion of the Italian picture to July 1832. This chronology helps separate the patron's initial commission from the much later New Hampshire canvas. The paintings were conceived years apart, although they would become companions. ^[4]

In 1839 Lord requested another painting to accompany the one he already owned. His instructions specified its dimensions and an American subject. They did not, on the evidence reproduced by Kelly, require Crawford Notch in particular. Cole's selection of this landscape should therefore be distinguished from the patron's documented requirement for American scenery. Lord created the opportunity; the particular view reflects Cole's choice. ^[2]

The pairing broadens the significance of the mountain pass. Kelly interprets the Italian picture's ruins as reminders of historical change and reads the later American scene against them. Old World scenery carried conspicuous remains of earlier societies; the American landscape, within Cole's nineteenth-century framework, invited speculation about the present and future. This is a scholarly reading of the pair, rather than a surviving explanation of every intention held by either artist or patron. ^[2]

Seen in that context, the small inn and modest cleared land become especially consequential. They represent a limited human presence rather than an established monumental civilisation. The mountain's prominence leaves open questions about how far that presence might extend and how secure it could become. The picture does not provide a sequence of events like The Course of Empire. Nevertheless, the companion relationship encourages a similar awareness that buildings and settlements exist within a landscape whose history exceeds their own.

From a July drawing to an autumn painting

The finished picture cannot represent the conditions of the sketching trip without alteration: Cole drew the site in July, while the canvas is filled with autumn colour. Kelly also distinguishes the lightly suggested sky in the drawing from the elaborate atmospheric drama of the painting. The season and weather were developed in the composition rather than copied together from that summer observation. ^[2]

Changes on the ground were equally deliberate. Cole reorganised a confused array of foreground stumps into two prominent broken trees at the sides and two sawn stumps nearer the middle. He moved the barn farther from the inn and reduced its scale. He made the road more conspicuous, allowing it to lead diagonally across the clearing and then turn towards the pass. Rider, figures, dog and stagecoach added different forms of human activity along that route. ^[2]

These changes serve different purposes. The repositioned barn makes the interval between the buildings easier to read. The road connects foreground and distance, giving the spectator a way through an otherwise formidable setting. The trees establish a strong frame but do not form an entirely protective enclosure: their broken limbs and irregular surfaces keep the foreground unsettled. The alterations help explain why the canvas feels both coherent and exposed.

Cole completed the painting late in 1839. A bill presented to Lord in March 1840 recorded $500 for the picture including its frame. Kelly suggests that work may have begun after Cole returned to Catskill in late July, but that starting point remains an inference. The documented completion and bill should not be turned into a precise day-by-day account of studio labour. ^[2]

The 1996 catalogue's technical examination adds another kind of evidence. Infrared reflectography revealed substantial underdrawing, which Kelly considered consistent with transferring much of the pencil design to the canvas. The technical notes describe a contrast between smoother passages in the sky and energetic, thickly applied foreground paint. These observations support a discussion of Cole's working methods, but belong to the examination recorded in that publication. Its account of varnish and minor damage is historical condition evidence, not a statement about the painting's condition today. ^[2]

Travellers beneath changing skies

The road supplies a human rhythm within the mountain's larger forms. The rider is the most conspicuous moving figure in the clearing. Farther away, people and a dog appear near the inn, while a stagecoach approaches the constricted passage. Their differences of scale let the eye follow the route into depth. Kelly identifies these elements as additions or developments beyond Cole's field drawing. ^[2]

The buildings make the valley seem inhabited and traversable. An inn implies a stopping place within a journey, and the coach evokes collective travel rather than the rider's solitary movement. Yet the painting does not give enough information to name the rider or establish the individual histories of the figures. Their pictorial role is clearer than their identity: they provide activity, a measure of distance and a human scale against the terrain.

Above them, the sky divides without separating neatly into two independent halves. Heavy cloud fills the upper left, pale blue opens at the right, and lighter vapour passes across the mountain. Sunlit foliage persists below the threatening atmosphere. The opposition creates suspense, but a painting cannot tell us with certainty which minute of a storm we are seeing. The safest description concerns what Cole painted: dark cloud, clear sky, veiled slopes and contrasting illumination.

Kelly reads the atmospheric drama, twisted trees and rugged forms as expressions of natural force. His interpretation does not depend on identifying a meteorological event observed in July. Indeed, the gap between drawing and canvas shows how Cole could use weather to organise emotional experience. The bright autumn colour offers pleasure at the same time that the clouds and damaged trees disturb any easy sense of permanence. ^[2]

Watch: Thomas Cole

Choose a film to explore the artist’s work, its interpretation and its wider setting.

Thomas Cole: Painting the American Landscape (remastered audio)

Thomas Cole National Historic Site

An introduction to Cole’s landscapes and artistic ambitions.

Watch on YouTube

▶01 · WatchPainting the American landscapeThomas Cole National Historic Site▶02 · WatchEden to EmpireThe National Gallery

The Willey disaster and the house in the picture

Crawford Notch carried a tragic association for nineteenth-century travellers. In August 1826 a devastating slide killed members of the Willey household and two farmhands. According to the account discussed by Kelly, the occupants fled their house into the path of the debris, while the building itself survived. The disaster became widely known through writing and tourism, drawing attention to the disturbing unpredictability of apparently solid mountain terrain. ^[2]

The house in Cole's painting is not the Willey House. It is the Notch House, an inn established by Abel Crawford and his son Ethan Allen Crawford in 1828. Cole did not paint the actual disaster site or show the family being overwhelmed. Kelly identifies the bare areas on Mount Webster with the slopes where the slide had begun, but distinguishes this association from a literal representation of the event. Keeping the two buildings separate is essential to understanding the picture. ^[2]

The disaster nevertheless belonged to the place's cultural memory. Kelly argues that at least some contemporary viewers would have connected Cole's landscape with the Willey story. The painting could evoke human vulnerability through a familiar location without depicting victims or reconstructing the fatal night. The small figures remain part of an ordinary journey; the knowledge brought by viewers could make that ordinariness feel fragile.

Kelly also proposes a relationship with Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Ambitious Guest, published in 1835. Inspired by the disaster, Hawthorne's story adds a young traveller who dreams of achieving distinction but dies with the family. Kelly sees a possible parallel between this solitary guest and Cole's rider moving towards shelter. His comparison is interpretative: it does not establish that the figure illustrates Hawthorne's invented character or that Lord requested a literary subject. ^[2]

The distinction leaves room for a richer encounter with the canvas. A viewer may consider the Hawthorne connection, or think more generally about travel, shelter and danger. Neither response requires a prediction that the painted people are about to die. The landscape's power lies partly in its refusal to show a catastrophe. Beauty and unease coexist in a scene where daily life continues beneath mountains that human beings cannot command.

Cut trees, enduring mountains

The clearing records human alteration of the landscape. Sawn stumps differ from the broken and weathered trees: they give a visible sign of cutting, alongside the road and buildings. At the same time, living trees cover the slopes in dense greens, reds and golds. The foreground brings several states of vegetation into proximity, so the picture contains growth, seasonal change, damage and deliberate removal.

Kelly interprets these contrasts through Cole's concern with the cycles of nature and the consequences of clearing land. The seasonal foliage and dead trees suggest different kinds of change, while the stumps introduce human intervention. In his reading, the canvas's tension extends beyond a threatened traveller to a national problem: if American identity depended on the distinctive beauty of its scenery, changing that scenery could damage what people claimed to value. ^[2]

The road complicates a simple opposition between people and nature. It makes the inn accessible and lets the viewer imagine entering the scene, while also marking a human claim upon the ground. Cole paints a landscape in which travel and habitation are already present. The question raised by the clearing is therefore one of relationship and extent: how can people occupy such a place, and what changes follow from their occupation?

The nearby comparison with The Oxbow is useful because Kelly discusses both paintings as American landscapes charged with questions about natural force and human change. Here, however, the narrowed mountain passage produces a more compressed experience than a broad river panorama. The spectator's eye is led towards an opening that remains overshadowed. The grandeur does not resolve the uncertainties; it makes them harder to overlook. ^[2]

From Lord's collection to Washington

The painting attracted praise at the National Academy of Design exhibition in spring 1840. Kelly reproduces a contemporary Knickerbocker review that admired its American scenery, autumn colour and dramatic sky. That response shows how readily the view could be understood as a statement of national artistic distinction. Its success did not require early audiences to agree on the more specific literary meanings later scholars have proposed. ^[2]

Its subsequent ownership is documented with some gaps. The catalogue records the Sturges family's belief that Jonathan Sturges acquired it from Lord or Lord's estate, while noting the lack of documentation. Later it passed through family ownership and dealers, including Vose Galleries, then the Sanitary Scale Company and Kennedy Galleries. This is not an uninterrupted sequence of precisely dated transactions. ^[2]

The National Gallery of Art purchased the painting on 25 May 1967 with the Andrew W. Mellon Fund. Its accession is 1967.8.1. Today the work's lasting interest rests in the relationship between its well-observed place and its carefully constructed uncertainties: a real pass, an invented autumn atmosphere, a modest refuge and mountains that dwarf every human undertaking below them. ^[1]

Photographs and the changing experience of the pass

A stereograph made by J. W. and J. S. Moulton in 1873–1881 presents Crawford Notch through paired photographic views. The two images belong to a format intended to create a perception of depth when seen through a stereoscopic viewer. Retaining the whole card makes that mode of looking visible alongside the mountain landscape. It is later evidence, produced decades after Cole’s 1839 painting, rather than a photographic check on every feature of his canvas. ^[5]

Crawford Notch, White Mountains, N.H., stereograph by J. W. & J. S. Moulton, 1873–1881. The whole paired-image card is retained to show its photographic format. Image: J. W. & J. S. Moulton; New York Public Library. Public domain historical photograph. Resized.

Crawford Notch summit, 28 January 2021. Snow and a modern road distinguish this regional view from Cole’s invented autumn landscape of 1839. Image: Ascended Dreamer. CC BY-SA 4.0. Resized. This image derivative is available under the same licence.

A January 2021 photograph shows the summit in snow, with a modern road leading between the slopes. It gives a useful regional comparison for the narrow passage and its continuing role as a route. Its season, vegetation and road belong to different circumstances from Cole’s invented autumn. The two photographs help readers separate an identifiable place from a fixed appearance: travel infrastructure and ways of representing the mountains have their own histories. ^[6]

Frequently Asked Questions

References

1. National Gallery of Art, “A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch),” collection record, undated, consulted 6 October 2026; artwork overview, inscriptions, provenance and exhibition history. https://www.nga.gov/artworks/50727-view-mountain-pass-called-notch-white-mountains-crawford-notch
2. Franklin Kelly, “A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch),” in American Paintings of the Nineteenth Century, Part I, with Nicolai Cikovsky, Jr., Deborah Chotner and John Davis, National Gallery of Art, 1996, printed pp. 87–95 (PDF pp. 103–111), including technical notes, illustrations and entry notes. https://www.nga.gov/content/dam/ngaweb/research/publications/pdfs/american-paintings-19th-century-part-1.pdf
3. Elizabeth Mankin Kornhauser and Tim Barringer, Thomas Cole’s Journey: Atlantic Crossings (2018). Career context and artwork/study metadata: catalogue entries 10–66 and chronology, PDF pp. 137–231 and 249–262; related Barringer essay passages, PDF pp. 23–66.
4. Elizabeth Mankin Kornhauser, “Manifesto for an American Sublime,” printed pp. 65–66 (PDF pp. 69–70), and Shannon Vittoria, “Chronology,” printed pp. 251–253 (PDF pp. 255–257), in Elizabeth Mankin Kornhauser and Tim Barringer, Thomas Cole's Journey: Atlantic Crossings, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2018. Selected passages on Wadsworth's itinerary and Lord's Italian commission. https://cdn.sanity.io/files/cctd4ker/production/be901737ad5f92e33d91db53c6dd8ce6ed47ff27.pdf
5. J. W. & J. S. Moulton, Crawford Notch, White Mountains, N.H., stereograph, 1873–1881; New York Public Library image via Wikimedia Commons. Source.
6. Ascended Dreamer, Crawford Notch Summit, photograph, 28 January 2021, Wikimedia Commons file record. Source.
7. Franklin Kelly et al., American Paintings of the Nineteenth Century, Part I (National Gallery of Art, 1996). Cole catalogue and both Voyage of Life sets, PDF pp. 91–124.
8. National Gallery of Art, Study for The Mountain Ford (1846), accession 2015.19.772. Collection record and open-access image.
9. National Gallery of Art, Tree Trunks (1825–1840), accession 2015.19.607. Collection metadata and open-access image.
10. Splash image source.

    Thomas Cole, A View of the Mountain Pass Called the Notch of the White Mountains (Crawford Notch), 1839. Oil on canvas, 102 × 155.8 cm. National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC, Andrew W. Mellon Fund, 1967.8.1.